A cycle of prosperity for Gaza's children

That the generation now growing up in Gaza inherits a cycle of prosperity rather than a cycle of war.

A child born in Gaza enters a place where the ordinary machinery of a life — a school term that runs to its end, a clinic that stays open, a shop worth restocking, a road that still goes somewhere — has been broken, rebuilt and broken again. What that child inherits is not only the damage. It is the expectation that this is simply how things are, and the narrowing of ambition that follows from it.

A cycle of prosperity is the only thing that has ever reliably broken that pattern, and it is not charity. It is built from the same materials everywhere: security that holds long enough for commerce to be worth attempting, schooling that is not interrupted, capital willing to enter on ordinary terms, and a political settlement durable enough that none of the rest is wasted. Each depends on the others, which is why partial measures have so little to show for themselves.

The position taken here is that this is a matter of specific arrangements rather than good intentions, and that those arrangements can be described concretely enough to argue over. That is the work of the book below.

Set out at length inPeace in the Middle EastA New Blueprint for Israel, a Palestinian State, and Lasting Stability

The protection of human potential

That superintelligence is built to extend what people can do, not to make most of them unnecessary to the economy that uses it.

When manufacturing moved offshore, the aggregate figures improved and the losses landed somewhere specific. Towns across the Rust Belt lost their place in the economy and never recovered it, while the gains were spread thinly enough to be felt by almost no one in particular. That asymmetry was not a law of nature. It followed from decisions about what was worth protecting, taken by people who assumed the adjustment would sort itself out.

The same decisions are being taken now about knowledge work, and far faster. Year after year, thousands of knowledge workers lose their positions, and the places most exposed are Silicon Valley and Silicon Alley — the very places building the systems that displace them. A generation was told to learn to code, to analyse, to write, to design. It is a poor outcome if the reward for acquiring exactly the capability the age asked for is to be told the capability is no longer required.

The argument is not against the technology. Superintelligence should be built, and it should be used. Responsibility means judging it by a harder test than capability alone: whether it widens the number of people able to use what they have, or narrows it. A tool that makes a hundred people formidable is a different proposition from one that makes ninety-nine of them redundant, and the difference between those outcomes is a matter of choice, not of inevitability.

Set out at length inThe Terracotta EconomyThe machines didn't take the work. They took the argument.